Research on Judging "Quality of Life": The Impact of Disability Simulations?

Within the disability community th use of disability simulations is controversial. The following reearch provides some insight into this topic.


Abandoning the Golden Rule: the problem with "putting ourselves in the patient's place"

Sunil KothariKristi L Kirschner

Brain Injury and Stroke Program, Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, The Institute of Rehabilitation and Research, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA.

Topics in stroke rehabilitation. 02/2006; 13(4):68-73. DOI: 10.1310/tsr1304-68

Abstract

A large body of evidence documents the difficulties health care professionals have in predicting their patient's beliefs or wishes. These difficulties extend from the predictions of very specific patient wishes (such as for life-sustaining therapies) to more global assessments of patients' lives as a whole (for instance, their quality of life). Although many explanations have been offered for this phenomenon, we discuss one that has not received as much attention: the conscious or unconscious adoption of what we refer to as Golden Rule thinking. This refers to our attempts to understand another person's situation by imagining what we would believe or want under similar circumstances, in other words, "putting ourselves in the patient's place." Although Golden Rule thinking would seem to be a promising strategy, studies show that it actually results in inaccurate predictions of patients' wishes or beliefs. These mispredictions, in turn, have significant clinical and ethical implications. We review possible reasons why Golden Rule thinking may be of limited utility in understanding our patients' situations and suggest alternate strategies to maximize our understanding of our patient's lives.

Source:

Recent Entries

Call for Paprs:'Leisure, Tourism and Caregiving'
Recreation and Society in Africa, Asia & Latin America Journal: Special Issue on 'Leisure, Tourism and Caregiving' Guest editors:            Dr…
Research on Judging "Quality of Life": The Impact of Disability Simulations?
Within the disability community th use of disability simulations is controversial. The following reearch provides some insight into this topic.Abandoning the Golden…
The Bamboo Train
Follow Mitch St.Pierre -- if you can keep up! …
The Global Disability Rights Library (GDRL)
The Global Disability Rights Library (GDRL) project announces that it is continuing to accept applications from potential deployment sites until…
Steal This Idea: An Idea Worth Copying from Curtin in Perth
Win an iPad in our Universal Design Competition Tell us how you would use universal design to improve life at…
2nd edition Destination:RT published
With articles about developments in Responsible Tourism in Destinations globally and case studies from Canada, the UK and Oman this…
Outcomes 5th International Conference on Responsible Tourism in Destinations, Edmonton, Canada
Nearly 200 delegates from 20+ countries attended. There was lively discussion and many excellent presentaions which can be downloaded from…
The Economist 3rd CSR Conference: People with Disability and the Right to Inclusion: What is the Role of Anthropocentric Companies?
Athens, Greece. 27 September 2011.The Economist magazine, in association with the National Confederation of Disabled people in Greece, organises the…