Destination Development and American Sign Language

This article on the proposed town of Laurent, South Dakota comes via the GEOGABLE listserve of the Disability and Geography International Network (DAGIN). Contact information follows the New York Times article:

March 21, 2005
As Town for Deaf Takes Shape, Debate on Isolation Re-emerges
By MONICA DAVEY

ALEM, S.D. - Standing in an empty field along a wind-swept highway, Marvin
T. Miller, who is deaf, envisions the town he wants to create here: a place
built around American Sign Language, where teachers in the new school will
sign, the town council will hold its debates in sign language and restaurant
workers will be required to know how to sign orders.

Nearly 100 families - with people who are deaf, hard of hearing or who can
hear but just want to communicate in sign language - have already publicly
declared their intention to live in Mr. Miller's village, to be called
Laurent, after Laurent Clerc, a French educator of the deaf from the 1800's.

Planners, architects and future residents from various states and other
countries are gathering at a camp center in South Dakota on Monday and
through the week to draw detailed blueprints for the town, which could
accommodate at least 2,500 people. Mr. Miller, who has been imagining this
for years, intends to break ground by fall.

"Society isn't doing that great a job of, quote-unquote, integrating us,"
Mr. Miller, 33, said through an interpreter. "My children don't see role
models in their lives: mayors, factory managers, postal workers, business
owners. So we're setting up a place to show our unique culture, our unique
society."

While deaf enclaves, like the one that existed in Martha's Vineyard decades
ago, have cropped up throughout the nation, this would be the first town
expressly created for people who sign, its developers say. Even the
location, in sparsely populated South Dakota, was selected with the intent
of rapidly building political strength for the nation's millions of deaf and
hard-of-hearing people, a group that has won few elected offices around the
country.

But in the complicated political world of deaf culture, Laurent is an
increasingly contentious idea. For some, like Mr. Miller; his wife,
Jennifer, who is also deaf; and their four deaf children, it seems the
simplest of wishes: to live in a place where they are fully engaged in
day-to-day life. Others, however, particularly advocates of technologies
that help deaf people use spoken language, wonder whether such a town would
merely isolate and exclude the deaf more than ever.

"We think there is a greater benefit for people to be part of the whole
world," said Todd Houston, executive director of the Alexander Graham Bell
Association for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing in Washington. "I understand
the desire to be around people like ourselves, and I don't have a problem
with that, but I don't think it's very wise. This is a little bit of
circling-the-wagons mentality, if you ask me."

Over the past 15 years, he said, it has become easier for the deaf and hard
of hearing to grow up using spoken language, because of a steady rise in the
use of cochlear implants, more early diagnoses and therapies for deaf
children and efforts to place some deaf children in mainstream schools. That
fact has set off intense political debate over what it means to be deaf and
what mode of communication - signing or talking - the deaf should focus on.

Those who want to live in Laurent, though, say their intent is not
exclusivity at all, but the inclusion of diverse people, especially those
who do not have the luxury of communicating with speech. "We are not
building a town for deaf people," said M. E. Barwacz, Mr. Miller's
mother-in-law and his business partner in creating Laurent. "We are building
a town for sign language users. And one of the biggest groups we expect to
have here is hearing parents with deaf children."

Ms. Barwacz, who intends to live in Laurent, is not deaf. She has two
daughters, one deaf and one not, and eight grandchildren, four of them deaf.
Nationally, experts report that some 90 percent of deaf children are born to
hearing parents, setting up a quandary, in some cases, about what language
to use in a single household.

As early as the 1800's, deaf leaders debated the possibility of a "deaf
state," said Gerard Buckley, an official at the National Technical Institute
for the Deaf in Rochester. But the notion came and went. Elsewhere, because
of proximity to schools and businesses tied to the deaf, large
concentrations of deaf people have gathered in cities like Rochester;
Washington; Olathe, Kan.; Frederick, Md.; and Sioux Falls, S.D.

The difference in Laurent, say some among the 92 families who have reserved
spaces in the town from as far as London and Australia, is that every
element of it would be designed with them in mind. The homes and businesses,
they said, would incorporate glass and open space for easy visibility across
wide distances. Fire and police services would be designed with more lights
and fewer sirens. High-speed Internet connections would be available all
over town, since the Internet and Video Relay Service have become vital
modes of communication for deaf people. And any shops, businesses or
restaurants would be required to be sign-language friendly.

Here in Salem, a dusty 125-year-old farming town of 1,300 three miles from
the proposed site of Laurent, people seem unsure of what to make of the
idea. "No one has ever come along and tried to start a town," said Joseph
Kolbeck, the local barber.

Along the quiet main drag through town, Mr. Miller and Ms. Barwacz, who are
originally from Michigan, recently opened a storefront in the old King Koin
Laundromat to create and promote Laurent. They moved to Salem not long ago,
choosing the area after surveying nearly the entire country looking at
factors like population, climate and cost of land.

Some people here wonder how the proposed town of 2,500 would mesh with
McCook County's 6,000 residents and its economy of corn, cows and pigs.
Others say they doubt Laurent will ever become reality.

Mr. Miller and Ms. Barwacz have revealed little about the costs and their
plans for financing Laurent. They say they are using family money, as well
as some from a group of "angel investors," led by a man with a deaf daughter
who wishes to remain anonymous. First Dakota National Bank is helping to
secure financing, and the two have optioned 275 acres so far. They say they
are spending about $300,000 for the planning work during the meetings that
will end on Saturday. Those who have reserved spaces in Laurent will be
expected to put down $1,000 deposits for condominiums and home lots within
the next few months.

For many of those people - from states like California, Florida and New York
- a move to prairie land in South Dakota (population 760,000) would seem to
be an enormous culture shock. But they plan to start businesses like shops
and restaurants, gas stations and hotels, and the benefits, many of them
say, outweigh any concerns they have about the location.

Lawrence J. Brick, a retired school administrator from Philadelphia, said
Laurent held attractions that most hearing people would struggle even to
grasp: no longer having to shy away from the neighbors, fearing he could not
communicate; no longer having to guess what a store clerk is saying about a
price; no longer having to apologize for being deaf.

Although some people argue that Laurent might isolate deaf people, H-Dirksen
L. Bauman, who directs the master's program in deaf studies at Gallaudet
University, said the plans actually marked an important collaboration
between the deaf and the hearing, one of a sort not always encouraged by the
deaf community. This is especially significant, he said, as more hearing
people are learning American Sign Language, now the fifth most-studied
language on college campuses.

"Hearing people are not welcomed in deaf residential schools, in deaf
clubs," Mr. Bauman said. "But there is no audiogram you will need to buy
land in Laurent, South Dakota. There's simply a commitment to live in a
visually centered environment that supports manual as opposed to spoken
language."

But Dr. Michael Novak of Urbana, Ill., who has been performing cochlear
implants since 1984, said he was convinced that the trend among the deaf was
actually shifting toward therapies that could help the next generation of
deaf people use spoken language.

"Communities like this have a real place for people who cannot or choose not
to use the hearing technology," Dr. Novak said of Laurent. "But over time,
that number will be reducing." He wonders then, he said, if the future of a
notion like Laurent might fade away.

For his part, though, Mr. Miller said reports of the "death of sign language
and deaf culture continue to be greatly exaggerated." Not everyone, he said,
is eligible for or would even want to receive technologies like cochlear
implants. "I do not want one for myself," he said. "I am very happy being
deaf. To me, this is like asking a black or Asian person if he/she would
take a pill to turn into a white person."


GEOGABLE DISCUSSION LIST

List owner and manager, Dr. Mike Dorn, invites you to also check out his new Disability Studies, Temple University weblog. An on-line community devoted to building Disability Culture in the Mid-Atlantic and Ohio Valley regions, http://isc.temple.edu/neighbor/ds

For information on GEOGABLE and links to learn more about managing your subscription, visit the following webpage, http://isc.temple.edu/neighbor/service

For more information on the Disability and Geography International Network (DAGIN), visit the Disability and Geography Resource, http://isc.temple.edu/neighbor/research

Recent Entries

Disabled? No, Just a Bit Stiff.
The connection between Universal Design, aging, and travel continues to surface. A unique "massively multi-player future forecasting role-playing experience" designed…
Universal Design, Development, and Inclusive Tourism (Spanish)
De la revista Rèport Amèricas: Part I: Part II: Rèport Amèricas. Impresiones New Gate Media Editorial Turística, Año VI,…
Busqueda Laboral: Hotel Inclusivo en La Argentina (Spanish)
Noticas de la Argentina con una oportunidade profisional:       Está llegando... UNITE!!! Dejanos saber tu experiencia en un CV.    ¿Estudiaste…
Tools to Aid the Green Travel/Inclusive Travel Convergence
Editor's note: The following excerpt from Marcus L Endicott's blog may contain unfamiliar language but it you stick with it…
Benchmark Games: The Sydney 2000 Paralympic Games
Benchmark Games: The Sydney 2000 Paralympic GamesRichard Cashman and Simon DarcyWith a Foreword by Karen TighePublished in conjunction with…
Tanni Grey- Thompson on Travel
Dame Tanni Grey-Thompson takes the world on tour with her in the Mail Online article, "Celeb travel: Tanni Grey- Thompson…
A Proud Member of ENAT
TFA at the Best of Britain & Ireland: 28-29 March 2009
Tourism for All UK will have a stand (No 374) at this exciting new showthat invites you to explore…